Art of Zen-Boom (part two)
by Mark Ulano
from his Pro Audio Review column
In part one we met our panel and discussed
their views on the responsibilities and philosophies of the Boom Operators.
We looked into the relationships that boomers have with other key players
during the making of movies and television, and we left off with their recommendations
for preparation and tools.
The panel : Laurence Abrams (LA), Rusty Amodeo (RA), Eric Carr (EC),
Patrushkha Mierzwa (PM), Andy Rovins (AR), Joel Shryack (JS), Jerome Vitucci
How does one become a Boom Operator?
One might assume that learning this craft begins in film school and yet
many film students won't even take on the job of boom person during student
productions, as if doing so would be demeaning. Thus boom operating has
remained an esoteric craft learned by the ancient process of apprenticeship
combined with modern-day trial and error. This and other phases of film
sound are often defined as menial or "merely technical" and interpreted
as "not creative". This is an unfortunate misconception since all creative
work is technical. Musicians must learn the technique of their instruments,
Painters, the technique of color and texture, photographers- light, dark
and photochemistry. Sound people are no different. Assimilation of technique
can be the doorway through which fine craft trancends itself, regardless
of the medium. Movies are hand-made and boom operating is the proof.
That being said, the world of movie making is clearly one driven by commerce
and in that world, the highest practitioners of the boom arts can earn triple
or quadruple the salary of a tenured college professor. This is not some
charitable accident. The economic responsibilities of Boom Operators are
substantial. They are charged with safely capturing the spontaneous performances
of some of the highest paid humans around. The per minute cost of downtime
for retakes on $20,000,000 talent is astronomical. The Boom Operators must
try to get it the first time, every time. This does not downplay the essential
partnership with ADR (looping) and all the other stages of post production
sound. It just emphasizes the value placed by many filmmakers and actors
on capturing the original performance.
Talk to us about the politics of the film set?
AR: It starts with knowing when to keep you mouth shut. The rest you figure
out unless you are socially challenged.
JV: As far as the politics are concerned, using the skills that you already
use in day to day life is a good start, especially if you have been surviving
successfully. Film politics have a thousand-faces, and change from project
to project. Some days are a pleasure. On other days you are dodging bullets,
as the hierarchy's behavior rears it's ugly head, and the ego-satisfaction
level supersedes the creative and practical process on every level. Even
with all that, the " patient will not die". I and we will all survive.
JS: ...Remember, you are equal to all the people working with you, but
you are not equal in respect to the process of the film. The filmmaking
process has it's hierarchies. They are spontaneously dictated hourly by
the realities of this huge undertaking. Be it a cranky actor, noisy special
EFX, or losing the light, learn your spot in this context as opposed to
making it a people power list.
PM: Everyone needs to understand the particular hierarchy and film politics
going on in the company you are working for. These are not necessarily the
same thing. Diplomacy is a must, but so is knowing when you can be ballsy
and have it work in your favor.
How physically demanding is this work?
PM: Extremely. One of the least understood aspects of our work is that
the Boom Operator must be fully functional in order to take a job in this
free-lance world. Most others can have broken lims, backaches, be pregnant,
have allergies, with stuffy, congested heads. The Boom Operator is a performance
artist like the actors, without the leeway of having outtakes. Many directors
are concerned if a steadicam operator has his weight-balanced rig on, ready
to work, but I've never heard anyone in my 70 features ever say ,"let's
go, everyone, the boom is up". Sometimes, it seems like we are invisable.
JV: It is extremely demanding and often painful, maybe even extremely painful.
Holding a pole above your head for 12-16 hours per day, in some countries
of the world, is punishment for criminal behavior. Oh, please can I be a
Boom Operator? Certainly not everybody's' choice of employment. Remember
to read my new book soon to be released, " Zen Boomism and the Art of Pain"
or "How To Keep The Divine Pole From Floating Away".
LA: Boom Operating is, indeed, physically demanding work. The fatigue that
results is not simply concentrated in the arms and shoulders, as one might
guess. Holding the pole over one's head for long takes, over and over, does
of course take it's toll on the upper body. But I find that a Boom Operator
experiences an overall fatigue resulting from a variety circumstances. In
many cases, you find yourself wedged into a tight corner between hot lights
and C-stands, or folded like a pretzel while hiding under a desk or in the
back seat of a car, or perched precariously atop a 12-foot ladder reaching
over across the wall of a set. Add to that the long hours and, of course,
the ultimate enemy of the Boom Operator... sore feet... and sometimes it
adds up to a pretty long day.
How do you deal with situations that are potentially dangerous to your
JV: Be smart, avoid them if you can, get hazard pay if you can't avoid
them. No shot is worth it.
LA: Fantasy and "suspension of disbelief" are terms often associated with
the creative process of conveying a story through film. This, indeed, is
the magic of filmmaking. "It's only a movie... no one really gets hurt."
Unfortunately, I think that during production on the set there is an element
of false reality that somehow believes that, there too, no one can really
get hurt. We often find ourselves doing things that I believe are truly
unsafe, but for some reason, we do them anyway. Is it because we think that
it's only a movie and no one really gets hurt? Is it simply because no one
wants to appear the sissy? For whatever the reason, it happens frequently
and the Boom Operator is often placed in a less than ideal situation. I
think that accidents that have occurred in recent years have instilled a
somewhat greater safety consciousness on the set, but it is nowhere near
where it should be.
PM: I work with fitness specialists or physical therapists looking for
better ways to do something or special exercises to strengthen specific
muscles. For FX shots- Having seen people be seriously harmed or die, I
am not shy about planting a mic or asking the mixer to call it MOS [filmed
without sound recording]. In EFX smoke situations I've met very few special
effects people who have the level of knowledge I'm comfortable with. By
now I own several masks and goggles for various vapors. This is a much-neglected
work hazard in our business. Also, for driving scenes with actors at the
wheel-I stay v-e-r-y far away.
AR: Try not to piss off the drivers, grips, or wardrobe people (they carry
scissors). Avoid working on music videos. Practice common sense.
Can you talk about the craft of using the Fisher Microphone Boom?
LA: When not forced into using a fishpole (for reasons generally having
to do with space limitations,) the Fisher Boom is a far superior method
of controlling microphone placement. (Note the possible exception of the
CueMaster... for details, see Steve "Rabbit" Schuneman, the only person
I know who admits to liking this unwieldy thing. In spite of my skepticism,
however, it is a superb alternative when operated by someone who knows how
to use it well.) The Fisher's long reach and multi-axis cueing controls
allow a great deal of flexibility and when the goal is to keep the microphone
in front of the actor, that kind of cueing control is essential. But in
the evolution of the filmmaking process, some changes have taken place in
recent years that have effectively robbed the Boom Operator of this effective
tool. Cameras have gotten smaller and lighter, film speeds have improved
requiring fewer lights, and the lighting equipment has gotten smaller...
all these things have contributed to a smaller and leaner production package
and the crews move faster as a result. It is perhaps for those reasons that
in some venues, and commercials are a prime example, the Fisher Boom looks
to some crew members like an unnecessary old-style relic that takes up too
much space on the grip truck and gets in everybody's way on the set. The
producer will want a specific reason as to why they should pay the extra
money, albeit very little, and the grips will want to know why it can't
be done with a fishpole, not that they have any right to ask. And the simple
answer that "this piece of equipment will allow the microphone to be placed
more accurately" will simply not suffice. There is no excuse for this, but
you'll almost never see a Fisher Boom on a commercial and you frequently
won't see it in other situations that would have benefited greatly from
PM: It is a dying skill in feature, MOW, many TV series. The Fisher Boom
takes the weight off the body of the boom operator and an assistant pushes
it as needed. The skill in learning the pulley system and hand controls
is really minimal. In some situations the retractibility offers advantages;
once a boom operator with a fishpole selects a length of pole, it is set
for the entire shot, but the Fisher retracts during the shot and essentially
can go around lights. Its good for marking territory, too.
JV: I don't have enough time to elaborate thoroughly, however the Fisher
Boom is a wonderful toy, and I love to use it. Unfortunately, most of today's
features, and even commercials, don't provide enough opportunities for their
use. Locations, logistics, politics and budgets are often prohibitive factors.
AR: A little bit of instruction helps, but most technique comes through
practice. Unfortunately it's become a lost art in single camera. One important
trick is finding the right position for the boom. and then picking the right
time to park it there.
RA: There are two ways to set-up the cueing (left-right motion) of the
mic. If the arm is set-up so that one must rest the cue lever on top of
the hand between the thumb and the first finger and push UP to cue, then
this is considered "film style". If one rests the hand on top of the cue
lever and must push DOWN to cue, then this is considered "tape style." Everyone
has their own preferences. With the introduction of the articulator back
in the early 1980's, a Boom Operator adds another possible hand cramping
dimension to the boom. This device, originally produced for operators in
England in the late 1970's, allows the mic to move in a vertical fashion.
This helps in following actors up a flight of stairs, and also for booming
children next to tall adults. There are now four different size arms available:
16', 20', 23', and 26'. In addition, some operators incorporate an offset
to get an extra foot out of the arm, but careful attention is in order for
balancing the arm to avoid tipping the tri-ped dolly over. On sitcoms, the
Fisher Boom may be operated from the Floor or from the Greenbeds, called
because of their color (also called "Parallels" because of the parallel
position to the set. When operating from the Floor, usually on videotape
shows, the arms typically 23 to 26 feet to extend beyond the camera operators.
The origination of the boom arms on the 'greens' came from the Lucy show
when Cameron McCullock suggested relocation of the arms for better audience
viewing. Good three dimensional depth perception is a must when operating
from the Greenbeds. Film shows typically use boom arms on the Greenbeds.
Most videotape shows, Soap Operas, Live Interview, and like use the booms
on the Floor since lights are usually hung on dead-hung pipe and no Greenbeds
What do you need to know about radio microphones?
JV: Radio mics are our friends. Don't be afraid of them. They are just
another tool, but quite a powerful tool. I love being part of a wireless
sound department. [MU note: This includes full time wireless boom] Free
to fly, free to fly. Remember you are the microphone placement engineer.
Optimum placement for the body mic is still very important, avoiding clothing
noise, and not burying them. Give them air. Understanding the actors' needs
is critical in making your body micing days comfortable. Being Stealth is
what you have to be. Don't Futz with the mics or the actors too much. Get
it right on the first try. Many an actor or actress doesn't like them because
they are uncomfortable. On some occasions they feel that their privacy is
at stake. Sometimes they are right.
PM: We have to put them on anyone wearing anything, and have them sound
true and quiet. We need to know how to monitor the signal and power of the
transmitter and receiver, also how the mixer configures his cart and antenna(e).
AR: Feng shui. Knowledge of electronics and RF transmission physics help.
JS: Don't hate radio mics, they are your friend. I always thought the easiest
rig was best. Avoid complicated gobs of tape, moleskin, etc., in the end,
extra added material will usually give you extra added noise. The best exception
to that rule is a kind of putty, made as a weatherseal for windows, it will
bond the mic to fabric, and dampen induced noises from the fabric and the
cable. Your choice to use radio mics will sometimes depend more on the Production
Mixer than the Boom Operator. The Mixer has to blend the darn things, and
some are all thumbs on the faders. Cater the micing complexity to the Mixer's
ability to blend all the plants, radio mics, etc. Remember, if they can't
mix it, they will probably think you are just an idiot, rather than oh my,
my mixing chops are weak!
What makes a Boom Operator good?
JV: Great Boom Operators Are Born, Not Made!
PM: Being amicable, intuitive, knowledgeable about other departments, having
a work-together attitude. Humor and a sharp wit don't hurt. You also need
stamina and a good temper.
AR: Paying attention, experience. A good Boom Operator is regarded as someone
who reliably gets quality sound with a minimum of disruption for the production.
EC: Focus, intuitive reasoning and prior preparation.
LA: There are many qualities needed to be a good Boom Operator, but it's
surprising to many people that one seemingly obvious characteristic is actually
NOT required. Many people think you need to be real strong to hold a fishpole
over your head for long periods of time. Yes, it's hard. But, no, it's not
all strength. I've seen small Boom Operators hold a pole steady for seemingly
endless scenes, take after take. And yet, in situations where an extra Boom
Operator was needed, I've seen a very buff production assistant or craft
services person pressed into service and I've watched them grit their teeth
together and arch their backs in pain only moments into what I thought was
a not-very-demanding scene. It becomes apparent that there is truly an art
to holding the pole. When asked to explain, however, I am at a loss for
words. Don't lock your arms? Use the forward arm for support and control
the pole with the back arm? Don't freeze into one single position, stay
relaxed, and shift your weight occasionally during the take? Easier said
than done and I think there's probably a lot more to it than that. In the
end, I think it's like many of the jobs that are performed on a film set:
no one can tell you how to do it... it's something you learn over time...
you have to just get the "feel" for it.
What is worst cardinal sin a Boom Operator can make?
PM: Projecting less than a cohesive department to outsiders.
LA: Talking too much. (Especially if you are telling the actor how to do
AR: Not paying attention.
EC: Imagining a shot could be "easy".
JV: Don't fart on set, and definitely don't hit on the actors. ( especially
the leading ones). No matter how many times they ask you, "How do you that"
, or "Oooooooh, you must have strong arms", forget about it.
What advice would you give to someone interested in a career as a Boom
JS: Booming is a great job, you get to see the whole project being made
right before your eyes, you hear it better than anybody else, and people
always come up to you and say, Boy your arms must be strong!
PM: Assess whether you are good at multi-tasking, being able to constantly
split your focus, being able to think ahead, being able to visualize multiple
solutions for any particular task, work out, work out, workout. A kick boxer
apprenticed with me and didn't have enough stamina! "Failure cannot cope
JV: Assist a good Boom Operator for a substantial period of time. Be sure
that a Boom Operator is what you want to be. You may be doing it for a long
time. Booming, could be but, is not necessarily a pre-requisite to becoming
AR: There are too many of us as it is. Apprentice as a utility persona
and pay attention.
What has been the most rewarding situation you have ever experienced
in your work?
PM: Hearing my husband, the mixer, rave about me to someone we didn't know
well. Also, the time I choreographed a master so well with the camera operator
that everyone saw shadows throughout the take, but none were in frame!
JV: Booming a fast paced, 5 minute, 360' steadicam shot with Larry McConkey,
in the 1 1 O' Brazilian Rain Forest, on " At Play In The Fields Of The Lord",
would be one my most rewarding experiences. I felt a tremendous amount of
exhilaration after successfully completing several takes. Starting with
a 100ft. Dolly move and continuing to boom a five page scene with the late
Ms. Lillian Gish, on "Huckleberry Finn" was spiritual. She practically never
had to refer to her script. She was in her 90's at the time. Standing on
a scaffold 10-1 2ft. in the air booming Jason Robards 1 1 minute take of
Eugene O'Neils " Iceman Cometh" was something else. I wasn't sure if I was
crying from the pain or the performance. Being hired again, again, and again.
AR: I boomed on Driving Miss Daisy, which went on to win Best Picture.
It was a great experience working on such quality material, with actors
like Morgan Freeman and Jessica Tandy, and a director, Bruce Beresford,
who really cared about sound and respected our needs. On a tough 41 day
shoot the only looping was for performance by some of the actors in smaller
EC: Watching my mixer pick up his Emmy's
RA: Carefully planning several plant mics and boom positions to work in
such a way that all production dialogue is usable. On "East Of Eden" (a
Movie-Of-The-Week for ABC Television) we recorded Foley in real time to
get all the sounds for the scene. The mixer was Bud Alper and the Boom Operator
was Gene Ashbrook. I was a Sound Utility person at the time. The Scene started
out with a large open field of livestock. Timothy Bottoms emerged from the
forest, screaming and waving his jacket over his head, towards his brother,
played by Bruce Boxleitner. I ran, just out of camera frame, approximately
100 yards slightly in front of Timothy with a Sennheiser 815 handheld shotgun
mic. Gene's fishpole was over Bruce. The camera was on a 50mm on a Titan
crane starting at a high point and then lowering to include the two brothers
when they embraced. At that moment, because of the wide angle, we could
not get our mics close, so Gene and I hugged each-other, with my mic in
hand to mimic the patting of the back. When the two actors ran off towards
the short wood fence in the distance (unrehearsed), we Foley footstepped
their feet which included the jump over the fence. When the scene was completed,
we received applause from the crew for our performance...very rewarding
indeed. [MU note: do not attempt this at home]
Last update : May 9th, 2000